Independent Contractor vs. Employee: A Choice Guide

Independent Contractor vs Employee, Are They The Same?

In the contemporary workforce landscape, the choice between hiring an independent contractor or an employee is a decision that holds significant ramifications for employers.

The distinction between the two not only affects financial considerations but also involves legal responsibilities and impacts the overall dynamics within a business.

This article aims to shed light on the nuances between independent contractors and employees, offering insights to help employers navigate the complexities of their workforce decisions.

What is an independent contractor?

An independent contractor, often synonymous with a freelancer, operates as a self-employed individual or entity providing services to another party. 

Unlike employees, they don’t receive traditional benefits like health insurance or employer-sponsored retirement accounts. This classification, also known as “freelancer,” brings forth a level of autonomy, allowing individuals to set their hours, rates, and availability.

What is an employee?

Contrastingly, an employee is someone hired by a person or company to perform services. They operate under a specified pay rate, with a written or implied employment contract. Employees work for agreed-upon hours or shifts, following the employer’s outlined duties and responsibilities.

With a general distinction between the two, we can go even further to differentiate independent contractors vs employees by classifying them. Here are some key concepts to properly know which is which:

Integral Role 

If the person’s work is essential to the business, they’re likely an employee.

Employment Laws

Employees are strictly covered by labor and employment laws. On the other hand, independent contractors are not covered by such regulations. 

Profit Impact

Individuals significantly impacting profits are more likely to be classified as employees.

Payment Interval

An independent contractor is usually paid after receiving an invoice. On the other hand, employees are usually paid on a set period. 

Hiring Method

Employees get their jobs through an application, which will be reviewed by the company’s Human Resources. A contractor will usually be hired by a person or a department that needs their services and will provide a contract to legally bind the two. 

Specialized Skills

A unique skill set may indicate an independent contractor, while easily replaceable skills lean toward employee classification.

Degree of Control

Independent contractors can determine their hours, work location, and specific end dates.

Progress Reports

Contractors usually provide regular updates and submit invoices for their work.

Self-Employment Deductions 

Independent contractors handle their self-employment taxes.

Multiple Clients

Typically, independent contractors work with multiple clients rather than being tied to one company.

Why Employers Hire Independent Contractors

Employers often opt for independent contractors when seeking individuals to work independently on short-term assignments. Engaging international contractors is also feasible without the need for a local branch.

Why Employers Hire Full-Time Employees

Despite additional costs, companies hiring full-time employees secure long-term contributors, ensuring continuity in their talent base. This choice helps mitigate the risk of contractor misclassification.

However, hiring employees abroad involves nuanced administrative procedures and unique risks, leading many companies to partner with experts like employer of record (EOR) services.

Pros of Hiring an Independent Contractor

  • Cost Savings:
    Contractors may earn more, but employers save on benefits, taxes, and office space. Moreover, the lack of benefits that an independent contractor is mandatory to have saves a lot of money.

  • Greater Flexibility:
    Employers can easily hire and dismiss contractors, adapting to project needs.

  • Reduced Liability:
    Set employment terms, reducing employer liability in legal claims. Moreover, they are not fully linked to the company due to their flexible aspect.

Cons of Hiring a Contract Worker

  • Less Control:
    Contractors operate independently, deciding on tasks and timelines. This means that their output and expected time of work widely vary.

  • Temporary Staff:
    Contractors work on specific projects, lacking loyalty compared to in-house employees.

Pros of Hiring an Employee

  • Company Loyalty:

    Employees often exhibit greater loyalty, supporting business growth.

  • Streamlined Training:
    While contractors require less initial training, frequent turnover may necessitate more time.

  • Brand Ambassadors:
    Employees, invested in the company’s growth, become natural brand ambassadors.

Cons of Hiring an Employee

  • Less Flexibility:

    Employees require a more committed, less flexible arrangement.

  • Employee Benefits:
    Additional expenses include taxes, pensions, and other benefits. This can mean a lot to a company that is only starting.

In conclusion, the decision between hiring an independent contractor or an employee is a pivotal one for employers. The distinctions in tax responsibilities, benefits, and the nature of work hold profound implications. 

Employers must carefully assess their needs, considering factors like project duration, financial commitments, and the long-term goals of their business. By navigating these complexities with a nuanced understanding, employers can create a workforce strategy that aligns with their organizational objectives.

Global People is a leading local employment solutions provider for national and international corporations and can advise and escort you in your next destination.


About Us

Global People aims to assist its clients to fully focus on their development and success in their target destinations without having to worry about the regulation and compliance involved in the employment of their local and expat employees.


Subscribe to our newsletter and stay up to date with global changes

We are committed to protecting your privacy


Popular Post

Get an Employment
Budget Simulation

For Salary Simulation please fill in the following information:
special end of year promotion
Use our team of experts & you will enjoy:

* Subject to availability and terms and conditions of the promotion

<!– Calendly inline widget begin –>
<div class=”calendly-inline-widget” data-url=”” style=”min-width:320px;height:630px;”></div>
<script type=”text/javascript” src=””></script>
<!– Calendly inline widget end –>